Best Short Day Onion Sets For Fall Planting

Best Short Day Onion Sets For Fall Planting: 9 Sets Compared

A strong fall-planting choice should state that it can be planted in fall and identify its day-length type; KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets is the clearest match on fall timing, but its listed varieties are intermediate-day, day-neutral, and long-day—not short-day. This roundup compares nine onion-set options, from an 8-ounce assortment to larger count packs, while separating confirmed details from claims the listings do not make. None of the nine products is verified as a short-day set, so shoppers in short-day regions should confirm variety and local suitability before ordering.

The options can still suit gardeners seeking fall planting, mixed colors, or green onions, provided the day-length mismatch is understood and checked against their location and planting schedule. Rank reflects the available product facts, not independent growing tests.

KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets leads because its listing explicitly says fall planting and gives a USDA hardiness range of Zones 3–10, alongside red, white, and yellow bulbs. Its varieties are described as intermediate-day, day-neutral, and long-day, however, so it is not a confirmed short-day choice. If short-day adaptation is essential, none of these listings establishes that fit; verify the named varieties and local planting guidance before buying.

Our Top Picks

KEJORA Tricolor Onion SetsBest Overall

KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets

The listing explicitly supports fall planting and USDA Zones 3–10, with three colors; its day-length mix is not short-day, so verify regional fit.

View on Amazon
TomorrowSeeds Three-Color MixCold-Stored Mix

TomorrowSeeds Three-Color Mix

A 1/2-pound pack of about 50 sets is stored cold, and its named varieties include intermediate-day Yellow Stuttgarter, Red Karmen, and Snowball White.

View on Amazon
Stargazer Mixed Onion SetsMost Sets Listed

Stargazer Mixed Onion Sets

The 1-pound pack typically contains 80–100 hand-sorted bulbs and includes a growing tip sheet, though its stated day lengths include intermediate, neutral, and long.

View on Amazon

Compare the onion set options

Detailed Reviews: Best Short Day Onion Sets For Fall Planting

KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets

#1 · Best Overall

1. KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets

  • Weight: 8 oz

Best for: Zone-spanning tricolor planting.

Why it ranks #1: The listing explicitly supports fall planting and USDA Zones 3–10, with three colors; its day-length mix is not short-day, so verify regional fit.

Coverage across USDA Zones 3–10 gives KEJORA’s red, white, and yellow onion mix a broad stated growing range, while its listing includes fall planting. That combination suits gardeners comparing a colorful assortment for seasonal planting, with the option to pick tender green onions early or leave bulbs to mature.

The mix includes intermediate-day, day-neutral, and long-day varieties, so it is not a single day-length type; that matters when choosing sets for a particular fall-growing plan. Its instructions call for planting 3–6 inches apart in loose, well-drained soil and watering consistently, giving buyers a concrete spacing and care routine. Harvesting at any stage offers a choice between tender greens and mature bulbs for cooking or storage.

Pros
  • Red, white, and yellow varieties in one assortment
  • Listed for USDA Zones 3–10
  • Fall planting is specifically mentioned
  • Can be harvested as greens or mature bulbs
Cons
  • The assortment mixes day-length types rather than specifying a short-day-only set.

Skip it if you want only short-day bulbs; the assortment includes intermediate-day, day-neutral, and long-day varieties.

Consider this assortment if you value color, a stated wide zone range, and flexible harvest timing. Its mixed day-length varieties make it a less direct choice when fall planting requires a specifically short-day set.

Full product details
BrandKEJORA
ColorRed, White, Yellow
Item FormWhole
Item Weight8 ounces
ManufacturerKejora
Additional InformationImportant information Ingredients Pearl Onions Tricolor yellow, white and red

Listed on Amazon as: KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets (Red White and Yellow Bulbs) Zones 3-10, Planting Spring to Fall -Non GMO 8oz

View on Amazon
TomorrowSeeds Three-Color Mix

#2 · Cold-Stored Mix

2. TomorrowSeeds Three-Color Mix

Best for: Three-color variety gardeners.

Why it ranks #2: A 1/2-pound pack of about 50 sets is stored cold, and its named varieties include intermediate-day Yellow Stuttgarter, Red Karmen, and Snowball White.

Yellow Stuttgarter, Red Karmen, and Snowball White bring three named onion varieties together in one set, giving gardeners a choice of colors and uses from a single planting. The mix is described as easy to grow, with green onions early and storage onions later, so it can serve both fresh meals and keeping.

The three-variety mix pairs early green onions with later storage onions, letting a gardener use the planting at different stages rather than choosing only one harvest style. Red, white, and yellow bulbs also add culinary variety, while the product is described as easy to grow for beginners. The listing identifies these as intermediate-day onions, but does not specify a short-day designation; fall planters seeking a confirmed short-day type should account for that distinction.

Pros
  • Three named varieties: Yellow Stuttgarter, Red Karmen, and Snowball White
  • Red, white, and yellow onions add variety to cooking
  • Can provide green onions early and storage onions later
  • Described as easy to grow for beginner gardeners
Cons
  • The listing identifies intermediate-day onions, not short-day sets.

Skip it if you need a clearly specified short-day variety; this listing identifies its mix as intermediate-day instead.

A good fit for gardeners who want three onion colors and both early greens and later storage onions from one planting. Choose another set if confirmed short-day classification is essential for your fall plan.

Full product details
BrandTomorrowSeeds
ColorGreen,Red,White,Yellow
ManufacturerTomorrowSeeds
Material FeatureGMO Free
Material FeaturesGMO Free
Care Instructionsmild

Listed on Amazon as: 3 Colors Mix Onion Sets (Bulbs) – 1/2 Pound (~50 Sets) – Fresh Crop, Stored Cold, for 2026 Planting Yellow, Red, White, Excellent Storage Noon Intermediate Intermediate Day

View on Amazon

Why it ranks #3: The 1-pound pack typically contains 80–100 hand-sorted bulbs and includes a growing tip sheet, though its stated day lengths include intermediate, neutral, and long.

A one-pound assortment typically containing 80 to 100 hand-sorted sets gives Stargazer Perennials buyers a larger mixed planting to work with. Red, white, and yellow varieties span intermediate, day-neutral, and long-day types, while an included growing tip sheet supplies guidance for planting and harvesting.

The 16-ounce quantity and typical count of 80–100 sets can support a larger home-garden planting, though the actual number varies with bulb size. Hand-sorting is stated to help ensure viability, and the included tip sheet offers planting and growing instructions. Care directions specify spacing sets 3–6 inches apart, pulling them when tops fall over, curing for 14 days, and storing in a cool, dry location—useful steps for planning the harvest workflow.

Pros
  • One pound of non-GMO onion sets
  • Typically 80–100 sets, with count varying by bulb size
  • Hand-sorted sets and included growing tip sheet
  • Care directions include spacing, curing, and storage
Cons
  • The mix includes long-day varieties, not just short-day sets.

Skip it if you need a short-day-only assortment; these sets include intermediate, day-neutral, and long-day varieties.

This suits gardeners who want a substantial, mixed-color planting and written growing guidance, including post-harvest steps. It is not the clearest match when fall plans depend on buying short-day onions exclusively.

Full product details
BrandStargazer Perennials
Colorred, white, yellow
Included Componentsonion sets, growing tip sheet
ManufacturerStargazer Perennials
Outer MaterialGmo free
Care InstructionsPlant 3-6 inches apart, pull when tops fall over, cure for 14 days, store in a cool, dry location.
Special FeatureNon-GMO

Listed on Amazon as: Mixed Red, White, and Yellow Onion Sets 1 Pound Non-GMO Bulbs for Planting – Onion Assortment

View on Amazon
Country Creek Mixed Starter Sets

#4 · Mixed Color Pack

4. Country Creek Mixed Starter Sets

  • Weight: 16 oz

Best for: Container-friendly mixed starter.

Why it ranks #4: This 50-count pack combines yellow, white, and red sets and gives planting guidance for both green table onions and dry bulbs.

The 50-count mix can grow either early green table onions or large dry onions, giving a small planting two stated harvest paths. Country Creek also says the sets can be grown in a window box or container, making this a practical option for gardeners without a conventional garden bed.

For green table onions, the instructions say to plant sets roots-down close together in a row, 2–3 inches deep, and harvest within 3–4 weeks. For large dry onions, the guidance instead calls for 3-inch spacing and shallow planting, so the same mixed set supports distinct planting workflows. Full sun and fertile, well-drained soil are specified; a window box or container is also an option where garden space is limited.

Pros
  • 50 sets in a yellow, white, and red mix
  • Can be grown for early green onions or large dry onions
  • Window boxes or containers are listed as options
  • Includes specific planting directions for green onions
Cons
  • The listing does not specify a short-day classification for the mixed sets.

Skip it if you need a confirmed short-day onion type; this product describes the colors and uses but not its day-length class.

A fit for gardeners seeking a 50-set color mix and a choice between green onions and dry bulbs, including container growing. Check the missing day-length detail against your fall-planting needs.

Full product details
BrandCOUNTRY CREEK ACRES GROWING IS IN OUR ROOTS
ColorMixed
Item Weight16 ounces
ManufacturerCountry Creek LLC
Care InstructionsPlant in full sun in fertile, well-drained soil. For green table onions: plant sets with roots down in a row as close as possible to each other and 2-3 inches deep, harvest within 3-4 weeks. For large dry onions: plant in a row 3 inches apart and only deep enough so top is barely covered or just vis

Listed on Amazon as: Mixed Onion Starter Sets (Yellow, White and Red) – 50 Count Set – Used to Grow Early Green Table Onions and Large Dry Onions – Country Creek LLC

View on Amazon
Country Creek Yellow 100-Count

#5 · Yellow Bulk Pack

5. Country Creek Yellow 100-Count

Best for: Quick greens and yellow bulbs.

Why it ranks #5: The 100-count yellow set offers a larger single-color pack; the listing says it can produce green onions in 2–4 weeks or storage onions.

Harvesting mild-tasting green onions in 2–4 weeks is the key appeal of this 100-count yellow starter set, with storage onions also listed as a later use. It gives gardeners one color of onion sets and two stated harvest goals, from quick scallions to bulbs for storage.

The listing connects the yellow sets with green onions or scallions just weeks after planting and storage onions the following summer, allowing the gardener to plan both an early and later use. Its care guidance calls for full sun and fertile, well-drained soil, which helps define the site and bed conditions before planting. The 100-count format provides many sets for a home planting, but no day-length classification is supplied for buyers seeking short-day bulbs.

Pros
  • 100 yellow onion sets
  • Green onions described as ready in 2–4 weeks
  • Can also produce storage onions for the following summer
  • Full sun and fertile, well-drained soil guidance is provided
Cons
  • No short-day or other day-length classification is provided.

Skip it if you need a verified short-day variety; this listing gives harvest uses but no day-length classification.

Choose this if you want a large yellow planting for quick greens and later storage onions, and can provide full sun with fertile, well-drained soil. Its day-length type is not specified.

Full product details
BrandCOUNTRY CREEK ACRES GROWING IS IN OUR ROOTS
ManufacturerCountry Creek LLC
Additional InformationImportant information

Listed on Amazon as: Yellow Onion Starter Sets – 100 Count Set – Easy To Grow Early Green Table Onion and Large Dry Onions Right At Home – Country Creek LLC

View on Amazon
Country Creek Yellow 8-Ounce Set

#6

6. Country Creek Yellow 8-Ounce Set

  • Weight: 16 oz

Best for: Yellow sets for compact growing.

Why it ranks #6: The 8-ounce yellow set is described for green table onions or large dry onions, but the listing does not identify day length or fall suitability.

An 8-ounce set of yellow onion bulbs offers a defined quantity for gardeners aiming to grow early green table onions or large dry onions. Country Creek notes that these can grow in a window box or container, so a traditional garden bed is not the only stated planting option.

The product description links its yellow bulbs to both early green table onions and large dry onions, letting buyers select a harvest goal without changing to a different listed color. Full sun and fertile, well-drained soil are specified, and the container option can help gardeners work with limited garden space. The listing calls the sets easy to grow, but it does not identify their day-length class, a relevant gap for a fall planting chosen specifically for short-day onions.

Skip it if you need a stated short-day variety; these yellow sets are not assigned a day-length class in the listing.

This is suited to gardeners wanting yellow sets for greens or dry onions, including those growing in containers. For fall planting, the unspecified day-length class is an important selection boundary.

Full product details
BrandCOUNTRY CREEK ACRES GROWING IS IN OUR ROOTS
ColorYellow
Item Weight16 ounces
ManufacturerCountry Creek LLC
Special FeaturesEasty To Grow
Special FeatureEasty To Grow

Listed on Amazon as: Yellow Onion Starter Sets – 8 Ounce Set – Used to Grow Early Green Table Onions and Large Dry Onions – Country Creek LLC

View on Amazon
Country Creek Red 50-Count

#7

7. Country Creek Red 50-Count

  • Weight: 16 oz

Best for: Red sets for slicing harvests.

Why it ranks #7: Its 50 red bulbs are presented for green onions or dry onions, with red onions noted as suitable for slicing; no day length is specified.

Red onions are specifically described as best for slicing, giving this 50-count starter set a clear culinary direction. The bulbs can also be grown for early green table onions or large dry onions, so the stated use is not limited to harvesting them as mature slicing onions.

The 50 red sets can be used for early green table onions or large dry onions, offering more than one harvest stage from the same color selection. Country Creek lists full sun and fertile, well-drained soil, while also noting that a window box or container can be used instead of a garden. The low-maintenance feature may appeal to home growers, but the supplied facts do not state a short-day classification for fall-planting decisions.

Pros
  • 50 red onion sets
  • Red onions are described as best for slicing
  • Can be grown as early greens or large dry onions
  • Container and window-box growing are listed options
Cons
  • No day-length class is supplied to confirm these are short-day sets.

Skip it if you require a confirmed short-day type; the listing does not provide a day-length classification for these red sets.

A useful option for gardeners who prefer red onions for slicing and want greens or dry bulbs from the planting. The listing’s missing day-length information matters if short-day fall sets are required.

Full product details
BrandCOUNTRY CREEK ACRES GROWING IS IN OUR ROOTS
ColorRed
Item Weight16 ounces
ManufacturerCountry Creek LLC
Special FeaturesLow Maintenance
Special FeatureLow Maintenance

Listed on Amazon as: Red Onion Starter Sets – 50 Count Set – Used to Grow Early Green Table Onions and Large Dry Onions – Country Creek LLC

View on Amazon
Country Creek White 50-Count

#8

8. Country Creek White 50-Count

  • Weight: 16 oz

Best for: White sets for container gardens.

Why it ranks #8: This 50-count white set offers a distinct color option and container-growing guidance, but the listing does not confirm fall planting or day-length type.

The option to grow these 50 white onion sets in a window box or container makes them relevant to gardeners without a conventional bed. The listing also gives them two uses—early green table onions and large dry onions—so a compact planting can serve more than one harvest purpose.

Country Creek describes the white sets as suitable for early green table onions and large dry onions, giving buyers flexibility in when to harvest. Full sun and fertile, well-drained soil are the stated growing conditions, while the container and window-box note offers an alternative to a garden plot. The listing identifies the bulb color and count but does not provide a day-length class, so fall planters cannot confirm from these facts alone that the sets are short-day.

Pros
  • 50 white onion sets
  • Can be grown for early green onions or large dry onions
  • Window boxes and containers are listed growing options
  • Full sun and well-drained soil requirements are stated
Cons
  • The listing does not specify whether these are short-day onions.

Skip it if you need a documented short-day type; these white sets have no stated day-length classification.

This suits container gardeners who want white onions for greens or dry bulbs and can provide full sun and well-drained soil. Buyers requiring short-day sets should treat the missing classification as a limitation.

Full product details
BrandCOUNTRY CREEK ACRES GROWING IS IN OUR ROOTS
ColorWhite
Item Weight16 ounces
ManufacturerCountry Creek LLC

Listed on Amazon as: White Onion Starter Sets – 50 Count Set – Used to Grow Early Green Table Onions and Large Dry Onions – Country Creek LLC

View on Amazon
Country Creek Yellow 200-Count

#9

9. Country Creek Yellow 200-Count

  • Weight: 16 oz

Best for: High-count yellow starter planting.

Why it ranks #9: The 200-count listing offers the largest stated quantity, but provides no verified short-day classification or explicit fall-planting guidance.

A 200-count set of yellow onion bulbs provides a large planting for gardeners seeking both early green table onions and large dry onions. Country Creek also lists window boxes or containers as possible growing spaces, though the high set count is most relevant to buyers planning a substantial planting.

The 200-set quantity gives buyers many bulbs to allocate toward the stated green-table or large-dry onion uses. The supplied growing guidance calls for full sun and fertile, well-drained soil, and permits container or window-box growing for those without a garden plot. The listing does not identify a day-length class, so despite the yellow color and two harvest uses, buyers planning specifically for short-day fall planting lack that confirmation.

Pros
  • 200 yellow onion sets
  • Listed for early green table onions and large dry onions
  • Container or window-box growing is mentioned
  • Full sun and fertile, well-drained soil guidance is provided
Cons
  • The product facts do not specify a short-day classification.

Skip it if you need a stated short-day variety; this high-count yellow set has no listed day-length class.

Consider this for a substantial yellow planting when you want greens or dry onions and have suitable sunny growing space. Its unspecified day-length type is a boundary for short-day fall plans.

Full product details
BrandCOUNTRY CREEK ACRES GROWING IS IN OUR ROOTS
ColorRed
Item Weight16 ounces
ManufacturerCountry Creek LLC
Special FeaturesLow Maintenance
Special FeatureLow Maintenance

Listed on Amazon as: Yellow Onion Starter Sets – 200 Count Set – Used to Grow Early Green Table Onions and Large Dry Onions – Country Creek LLC

View on Amazon

The short-day label is the key compatibility check

None of these nine listings verifies a short-day variety, so confirm day-length classification before treating any as a match. KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets names intermediate-day, day-neutral, and long-day varieties; Stargazer Mixed Onion Sets also lists intermediate, day-neutral, and long-day types. TomorrowSeeds Three-Color Mix identifies its varieties as intermediate-day.

See also  Best Rated Pod Coffee Makers: Top 10 Picks

The Country Creek listings generally identify color and intended use but not day length. This matters because an onion’s day-length response is tied to the seasonal light conditions at bulb formation, and a mismatch can prevent the bulb development a gardener expects.

Do not infer short-day suitability from a product’s color, “fall planting” wording, or broad hardiness-zone range. Ask the seller for the variety names and day-length group, then compare them with local extension guidance for your location.

Fall planting and winter survival are separate questions

A listing that says fall planting does not by itself establish that sets will overwinter successfully in every garden. KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets names fall planting and Zones 3–10, but the supplied details do not give a planting date, winter-protection method, or survival guarantee. Country Creek’s sets include full-sun and well-drained-soil guidance, but do not specify an overwintering protocol.

The practical trade-off is between buying a pack with explicit fall language and obtaining clear advice for your local climate: the first is easier to screen, while the second still needs local confirmation. Check planting windows, drainage, and winter conditions with a regional source before planting.

Also distinguish green-onion harvesting from mature dry-bulb production; a set may be usable as a green onion without proving that it will form a full storage bulb in a given season.

How to Choose Onion Sets for Fall Planting

Fall-planting evidence

Look for an explicit fall-planting statement rather than assuming any onion set can be planted in autumn. KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets specifically says planting spring to fall and gives Zones 3–TomorrowSeeds Three-Color Mix is described as ready for planting, but the supplied facts do not confirm a fall schedule.

The Country Creek sets describe growing uses and soil conditions without an explicit fall claim. Gardeners who want the clearest listed timing should start with KEJORA, then check local planting windows; those choosing another pack should confirm timing with the seller or a local growing guide before planting.

A broad zone range is useful context, not a guarantee of overwintering success.

Day-length classification

Choose a verified day-length group suited to your location; do not treat color or season wording as a substitute. TomorrowSeeds Three-Color Mix identifies its varieties as intermediate-day. KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets and Stargazer Mixed Onion Sets each include intermediate, day-neutral, and long-day types.

The other Country Creek products do not provide a clear day-length classification in the supplied information. Since the search is for short-day sets, buyers who specifically need short-day onions should verify the named variety before purchase rather than choosing any of these by default.

Gardeners flexible about day length may consider the listings with named categories, while those needing a precise short-day fit should keep searching unless the seller confirms it.

Pack format and intended harvest

Match the pack’s stated size or count to the number of plants and harvest type you intend to manage. TomorrowSeeds Three-Color Mix provides about 50 sets in 1/2 pound, while Stargazer Mixed Onion Sets lists 1 pound and typically 80–100 bulbs. Country Creek options range from 50-count red, white, or mixed packs to yellow packs listed at 100 and 200 count, plus an 8-ounce set.

The product data does not provide a consistent bulb-size measure, so counts and weights are not directly interchangeable. A mixed pack suits gardeners seeking color variety; a single-color or higher-count pack fits a larger planting of one type.

Buyers focused on early greens can also compare stated green-onion uses, but should not equate that with confirmed mature bulb performance.

Which Onion Sets Should I Choose for Fall?

For the clearest stated fall-planting option, choose KEJORA Tricolor Onion Sets: it names fall planting and Zones 3–10, but verify its non-short-day varieties against your needs. For a mixed pack with named intermediate-day varieties and cold storage, consider TomorrowSeeds Three-Color Mix. If you want a larger mixed assortment and included growing instructions, Stargazer Mixed Onion Sets lists 80–100 sets and a tip sheet.

For a single-color planting, Country Creek Yellow 100-Count or Yellow 200-Count offers more listed bulbs, while the red and white 50-count packs provide color-specific alternatives. None is confirmed short-day, so buyers who require that classification should get seller confirmation or select a verified short-day product instead.

Frequently Asked Questions

When should I plant onion sets in fall in my USDA zone?

Check the planting guidance for your USDA zone and the named onion varieties before buying or planting. The KEJORA listing explicitly says spring to fall and lists Zones 3–10, but its varieties are not short-day. Local conditions and variety suitability matter, so confirm timing with reliable local guidance rather than relying on a broad zone range alone.

How can I tell whether an onion variety is short-day or intermediate-day?

Look for an explicit day-length classification in the listing or in reliable information about the named varieties. A listing that calls varieties intermediate-day does not establish that they are short-day. If the classification is missing or unclear, ask the seller to confirm it before purchasing, especially if short-day adaptation is essential for your location.

How do I protect fall-planted onion sets through winter?

Follow local winter-protection guidance for your area and the specific varieties, since the listings do not provide a universal winter-care method. Confirm that fall planting suits your zone, then use locally recommended protection against winter conditions. The KEJORA listing gives Zones 3–10, but that range alone does not confirm short-day adaptation or guarantee suitability.

Does any listed option confirm short-day varieties?

No. The article’s listings do not establish a confirmed short-day choice. KEJORA names varieties described as intermediate-day, day-neutral, and long-day, while the other listings do not confirm short-day classification in the supplied information.

If you require short-day onions, verify the named varieties with the seller or choose a product explicitly identified as short-day.

Should I choose a mixed set or a single-color pack?

Choose a mixed set if you want red, white, and yellow bulbs together; choose a single-color pack if you want to focus on one listed color. The product titles identify mixed options and separate yellow, red, and white packs. Compare the listed quantities and confirm variety suitability before deciding.

Final Words

For a clearly stated fall-planting option, KEJORA is the strongest match in these listings: it names fall planting and Zones 3–10, but its varieties are not confirmed short-day. Consider TomorrowSeeds for a mixed pack with named intermediate-day varieties, or Stargazer for a larger assortment with instructions. For one color, compare the listed Country Creek packs.

If short-day adaptation is essential, verify the varieties or choose a confirmed short-day product.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *